The Short Version
Monday’s City Council meeting should have been easy and short, but it wasn’t. The Transit Oriented Development came back - again - at Monday’s meeting. CM Culver, Planning Commission Chair Banaszynski, Planning Commissioner Lassalle, and others pushed for a 10th extension of the “interim TOD regulations” which had been put in place as the result of Chair Banaszynski’s 2022 “Minority Report” where she was the sole signatory. To date, that report, the interim regulations, and subsequent renewals have cost the City 2,900 hours of Staff, Council, and Planning Commission time (not to mention consultant and legal time and cost).
Council could not agree to extend temporary regulations, or pass the permanent ones, so the TOD temporary regulations lapsed. This ended all restoration incentives for Swamp Creek in the TOD as well as opened the door to the most likely development for this area – townhomes. This decision makes the TOD substantially more likely to be redeveloped than it would have been had Council passed the permanent regulations, and will provide no incentives to restore the critical areas.
New permanent regulations are likely to be at least two years away as Planning Commission works through the Shoreline Plan and Critical Areas Ordinance in 2027 and 2028, incorporates any updates from Ecology, and the recommendations return to Council.
Council held public hearings on the Property Tax Levy for 2027, as well as the Walkways and Waterways bond. The results of the Salary Commission’s work were presented, and Councilmembers will receive a 10% pay increase next year.
November 16, 2026 City Council Meeting Recap
APPROVAL OF AGENDA
MOTION: CM Adman moved to amend the agenda to add the ordinance to extend the Interim TOD regulations ahead of the adoption of new regulations to the agenda. CM Culver seconded.
CM Culver advocated to extend the TOD regulations; this will be the 7th consecutive meeting where the “public record is unanimous” in asking for the TOD regulations to be extended.
Mayor Herbig said a lot of time has been spent on this, with multiple position-changes, and it’s not good governance to flip-flop this way. This takes a lot of staff work, council time, and shows them to be an indecisive body. He hopes Council can do better in the future.
CM O’Cain echoed Mayor Herbig’s comments. The TOD has come before council many times, and the concerns for a long-term plan have been heard by Council; it’s going to take time to do the long-term planning that is required. She does not see the benefit of the interim regs; Staff’s recommendation is incrementally better, and incorporates Council’s direction to incorporate housing and environment in this area.
CM Adman said he met with some members of the community after the last meeting and his position changed. He wants to respect all the people who have asked to have this discussed one last time.
CM Loutsis expressed that he did not understand why this was going to be discussed before the adoption of the permanent regs. He moved, with CM Adman’s support, to discuss it after. CM Loutsis made a motion to move the discussion. The amendment passed 6-1 with CM Culver opposed.
Main Motion: Failed 3-4 with CMs O’Cain, Loutsis, Marshall and Mayor Herbig opposed.
PROCLAMATION
Hunger and Homelessness awareness week. Received by Barbara Osborne from the Northshore Senior Center volunteer pantry manager, and Pasha from Northshore Senior Center.
WHERE IS THE FUN?
Tree planting events, co-hosted with Sno-King Watershed Council. Stormwater Awareness Week / Adopt-A-Drain. The “Draineys” highlight the drains that have been visited the most and have the silliest name.
PUBLIC COMMENT
Eleven people signed in to speak. The first two spoke about the potential Moorlands Elementary closure and the impact on Kenmore residents including traffic and park use. One commenter spoke about excessive delays, roadblocks and fees from the City as he has been trying for the last 4.5 years to create 27 units of affordable housing. Seven commenters spoke about extending the TOD regulations; one spoke about the budget, and one presented a housing plan.
Planning Commissioner Edouard Lassalle asked for the interim TOD regulations to be extended one more time, rather than “rushing in” to a decision. He believes that the proposed regulations are directly in conflict with the Council priorities that put the environment over all but financial health, and that they put density over ecologically sensitive areas. He doesn’t believe that waiting costs the City housing.
Planning Commission Chair Tracy Banaszynski spoke about the interim TOD regulations. She said she is not confused about the ordinance and believes that it re-zones entire parcels and pushes density into the shoreline zone. She referred again to her minority report which was the proximate cause of the interim regulations and subsequent discussions. “The permanent ordinance is not right for Swamp Creek.”
CONSENT AGENDA
Approved unanimously.
PUBLIC HEARINGS:
PROPERTY TAX LEVY
Presented by Melinda Merrell. Melinda explained the calculations behind how they arrive at the property tax levy request. We do not have any banked capacity, so the request reflects the 1% increase, refunds, and new construction. Their proposed 2027 levy is a total of 1.77% increase over 2026.
WALKWAYS & WATERWAYS
Presented by Melinda Merrell. This is an updated request for the Walkways and Waterways bond to reflect the payment that needs to be made for principal and interest in 2027. The average cost for homeowners in 2027 is about $126.
In response to CM questions, Melinda said that these are bond payments and there is some maintenance and operations cost that is in the capital fund. The bonds are 20-year bonds and end in 2039 and 2041.
BUSINESS AGENDA
BUDGET AMENDMENTS
Melinda presented the adjustments proposed from the previous meeting.
CM Loutsis moved to adopt; DM Sasson seconded. The motion passed unanimously.
SALARY COMMISSION
Michelle Kang presented. The Salary Commission convened on October 22nd and determined a 10% raise effective January 1, 2027, then four annual CPI-W increases beginning January 1, 2028. Commissioners requested that Council consider a future policy for councilmember stipends for childcare that give consideration for equity and access.
TOD INTERIM REGULATIONS
Samantha Loyuk and Brittany Chue presented. Sam restated that the proposed regulations do not change anything within the Shoreline area; they decrease the default maximum building height outside the 200’ shoreline area, and allow developers only to achieve it if they provide Swamp Creek restoration inside the shoreline area. If the regulations lapse, and no new regulations are adopted, the TOD parcels will default to the 2015 code, which allows townhomes. Adopting the regulations now requires an “Emergency Clause” so that there isn’t a lapse in regulations between when the interim ones expire and the new ones take effect; the ordinance can be passed with a simple majority but including the “Emergency Clause” requires a supermajority.
CM O’Cain expressed that she had heard the community’s concern about protecting Swamp Creek, and that everyone on Council wants to protect the creek. The proposed regulations are more protective than the interim regulations, and Council could pass them now and come back and strengthen them next year. She asked staff a number of questions on the proposed and interim ordinances, which revealed the following:
There is no difference in density between the proposed and interim TOD regulations (both are min: 60 dwelling units/ac and max: 150 du per acre).
There is no substantial difference in where an 85’ building can be built. Developers can currently choose between underlying and TOD overlay. TOD has a max of 65’ for all parcels; in the underlying zoning, 6 commercial parcels the max is 85’, some can have 60 or 80’ with transfer of density credits, some have a max of 60’. The new regulations would be 65’ with no restoration, 85’ with restoration.
There is no difference in the distance from Swamp Creek where buildings can be built under the interim and TOD regulations. The shoreline regulations remain the same at 200’, and this ordinance does not impact that area.
Staff has spent 280 hours on the TOD and carveout this year (as of early November); they have spent 1900 hours in total since 2019, not including Planning Commission, legal, consultant or City Council time. The work has always been at Council direction.
The Department of Ecology will have a final draft in March or April; to implement the recommendations, Staff will incorporate them into the Planning Commission’s work about the Shoreline Master Plan and Critical Areas Ordinance. That will take about 18 months. That’s to do all the work within the 200’ Shoreline Jurisdiction
The building height cap within the shoreline jurisdiction varies from 35’ to 65’.
Council does not have to wait for the Department of Ecology to make changes to the density outside the Shoreline area.
If they pass something today, they can come back and amend the regulations as they wish. These are “permanent” because they don’t have a six-month temporary clock. Staff is already beginning the work on the Shoreline and Critical Areas.
The 13 parcels are on already-developed land. The intent of widening the 200’ shoreline jurisdiction is for the preservation of areas that are not already built-out, so this would likely not be an area where that would apply.
This is not part of Staff’s 2027 workplan, so things would have to be moved around to accommodate. One of the major foci for next year is kicking off the Shoreline and CAO, and this could impact that.
In response to questions from other Councilmembers:
City Manager Killgore said that this is on Planning Commission’s docket so that they begin work on the Shoreline Master Plan earlier and incorporate the Stream Buffers. That will be the primary task starting next year and into 2028. Six or 12 months of interim regulations will not be enough to bridge the gap; this is an 18-24 month horizon. Staff is proposing the “permanent” regulations from an efficiency standpoint.
Sam said the reasons the TOD interim/permanent regulations are listed as a City Council workplan item as a placeholder in case the interim regulations were not renewed.
Brittany said that the density from the 2015 regulations is the same.
If the interim regulations lapse, anything that was passed through the interim zoning regulations would no longer be valid, but anything passed through permanent regs would be valid. The main difference is that townhomes were prohibited under interim regs, but they would be allowed again. There is still a TOD area, it’s just the one from 2015 and other permanent regulations.
Mayor Herbig said his main concern was improving the shoreline area of Swamp Creek. Because these are private property, we can’t restore them. We would need eminent domain and millions of dollars to do the restoration work, and he doesn’t see a world where this happens. His goal is buffers that are ecologically functional, and the path he sees is through restoration incentives.
DM Sasson said that she was “grumpy” because of her distress, and that of her fellow Councilmembers, in witnessing the distress of the community members in advocating for the health of Swamp Creek. From the perspective of governance, she feels appalled at the amount of time Council has taken on this decision. She believes that extending results in the same conversation in six months, and because Ecology recommendations will take a lot of PC’s time next year, they’ll have it again in 12 months. She does not want to do that. Council is on the side of restoring Swamp Creek and the waterways, but to keep on holding this as a placeholder does not make sense.
Motion: Mayor Herbig said he would entertain a motion to Adopt 26-0654, with emergency clause included. CM O’Cain made a motion to adopt 26-0654 with the emergency clause removed. CM Loutsis seconded.
CM Marshall said this was a close motion for him; if they don’t do something now and get an application they get less protection, but he still feels that the height is too high and would advocate for five stories maximum.
CM Adman said that his perspective has changed after meeting with community members and learning why they were advocating for the interim regulations. He’d previously viewed this as a binary choice between interim regulations and permanent regulations. He believes that they can recover the density lost in the TOD elsewhere. Tracy Banszynski’s minority report regarding the TOD requested that they re-draw the boundaries, or find a way to conserve the land along Swamp Creek (acquisition, conservation easements). Her minority report led to the interim regulations and nine more extensions of the temporary ordinance; this would be the 10th. He believes the interim regulations are problematic, and the environmental community thinks the permanent regulations are problematic because they allow too much height. He believes the best option is to let the regulations expire and revert to the underlying zoning. There’s no way to predict how competitive the City would be in a conservation futures grant, but there are multiple instances where there have been older properties that haven’t been redeveloped where they can get money to buy the whole property or get a conservation easement.
CM Culver said the minimum density is problematic because it treats the parcels as a whole in calculating density, and other TODs in the area don’t have a minimum density. It also raises the pavement cap from 85 to 90% on the re-zoned parcels. The height bonus sounds appealing, but Ecology’s rule says that when a site with a degraded buffer redevelops the program requires restoring or widening it. He doesn’t believe we should “pay for the restoration” with 20’ of permanent height when we could just require it. He again said that “our community has been unanimous on this”.
CM Loutsis said he cares very deeply about the health and well-being of Swamp Creek, and that’s led him to the position that he takes today. He’s in favor of capping impervious surfaces or requiring restoration; he opposes the interim regulations. They are less ecologically beneficial than the proposed regulations. What the environmental community is saying is to adopt the interim, but it’s clear that they are less beneficial than the proposed regulations. When faced to pick one or the other, he would wholeheartedly pick the recommendations that encourage restoration. He would also support re-looking at them to make them go farther, looking at conservation futures, and making the regulations go farther. The proposed regulations are not permanent, and we can look at integrating Ecology’s recommendations. The interim regulations are too problematic for him to support them. They won’t end after six months, and it’s not feasible for Staff to add this to their work plan in the next six months. What he’s left with is interim vs. proposed – the proposed are better. If the proposed regulations are adopted, he supports looking at further visioning as Staff capacity allows and after we receive Ecology recommendations. He would favor letting the regulations lapse over the interim.
In response to CM Questions about what happens if the Interim ordinance expires:
The City Attorney said that if these lapse, the 2015 TOD and underlying zoning would apply. There have been some tweaks in STEP housing, and those would apply. There is no six-month review timeline if the regs lapse. There would be no need for additional action.
Sam said the density would apply outside the shoreline areas, since shoreline is not impacted.
Brittany said the density would be the same for the commercial side (60-150du per acre) and the TOD would still be the 60-150du per acre. The maximum height is 65’.
CM Adman realized the TOD overlay was something that applicants could elect to develop under. So they can go to the increased density but they don’t have to.
CM O’Cain asked for clarification about the density if they let the regs lapse. Her concern from the beginning was the density in the commercial zones. She would like to see more pervious surface and lower building heights. What they are doing tonight is for 13 parcels, which is just one piece of the Swamp Creek puzzle. She appreciated community comments, and they need to, as a council, have a long-term vision not just for Swamp Creek but for our whole community. These last-minute changes and not respecting previous votes and positions make the job very difficult. The difference between the underlying regs and proposed are nominal. It’s important that we’re respectful as a council, and that we engage our community for a long-term plan.
Mayor Herbig said that the townhome issue was central to the reason that they passed the interim regs. Council wasn’t excited when there was a townhome development, because one of the areas with the most economic potential was filled with mid-density housing. They lost the opportunity to push commercial on the ground floor. Going back to the underlying zoning reopens it for townhome development on Bothell Way when that could be something more useful and needed for our community, like third places and shopping options. For that reason he can’t support going back to the underlying zoning, even though he recognizes that development has slowed and we’re unlikely to see any. He does want to figure out a long-term vision that protects Swamp Creek. The TOD interim regulations had very ambitious housing goals, and his concern was that they were creating through zoning the outcome that nothing would ever pencil out in that area. Unless we create an environment where redevelopment happens, the current state of affairs will go on forever. We need to work with the property owners and recognize that we are creating a zoning environment that doesn’t allow development – that’s the harsh reality of development that we often overlook.
CM Loutsis said that ARCH had a big fancy calculator and they figured out that the affordability goals could be achieved by reducing constraints elsewhere. The market has shifted over time, and maybe it’s wise to reevaluate that. We are trying to hash so far to find a perfect solution that we either don’t want to do anything or to do something that’s even worse, like the interim. We should try to find more incremental steps and regulations – adding restoration, tweaking affordability goals. If renew the interim or we let these lapse we don’t get any restoration for the next two years.
CM Culver said there’s a conflict in the idea that not expecting any development for the next two years, but it’s important that we pass this so that some could happen. He said that “there’s a great conflict at the center of this and [he] know[s] everyone sees it, [he] just [has] to be the one to name it.”
VOTE: Motion failed with CMs Culver, Marshall, Sasson, O’Cain and Adman opposed.
The TOD will revert to the 2015 TOD regulations and underlying zoning on November 19th.
STAFF REPORTS
City Manager Kilgore said that staff went back to the drawing board on the Arrowhead project. They will be installing chicanes for a six-month pilot and monitoring speeds to see how or if traffic patterns change. There will be a pilot on 202nd in partnership with the City of Bothell where people can try out speed cushions.
COUNCILMEMBER REPORTS
CM O’Cain expressed disappointment that the developer who spoke in public comment has had such a difficult time converting the hotel into 27 units of affordable housing. If it’s $150k in fees that is stopping the housing from being built, she’d rather waive the fee and have the housing. She’s heard more than once from people working in Kenmore that it can be very difficult to get through the permitting process. She spoke about the Mountains to Sound Greenway event, and would like to see the Swamp Creek project on their parade. She spoke about the Transformational Travel Institute, and wants to be on the cutting edge of creating a healthy, beautiful, prosperous future for Kenmore. She’d like to bring the naming ordinance to a future meeting in January. Working together as a body is really important, and she knows there’s been disappointment that Prop 1 failed, but this doesn’t mean that the people who voted against it didn’t care about climate, housing and human services. She believes Council needs to look at what’s going on for our community and why they couldn’t vote for it, and be responsive to our community. Council has raised many taxes over the previous years that had an impact. She hopes Council can have a long-term vision and respect for one another. Free Palestine.
MOTION: CM O’Cain moved to bring the naming ordinance to a future meeting. CM Marshall seconded.
CM Culver said that we’ve had a decent bit of criticism for monuments and special projects.
CM Loutsis said it was helpful for us as a council if we have clear guidelines in the future. Having something on the books that they can point to will help avoid sticky situations.
VOTE: Motion passed 6-1 with CM Culver opposed.
CM Marshall expressed condolences for the families of the Spokane County Sheriff’s deputies who were killed responding to a domestic violence call.
CM Culver said he’s interested in more Prop 1 debriefs. Free Palestine.
CM Loutsis said he’s ready to work with his colleagues and the community on a future vision for the TOD.
CM Adman said that we have control over the riparian zone of Swamp Creek in Kenmore, and that Snohomish County is in the process of doing their Critical Areas Ordinance. They’re having a hearing on December 2nd on their CAO. He encouraged people to ask them to follow Best Available Science.
DM Sasson spoke about the Northshore School District issue. She’s clear that this is not in City Council’s jurisdiction, but the speakers today brought home that it will have impacts on traffic and land use. It’s very unfortunate that the community is gnashing at each other, and she’s encouraged the impacted schools to come together. She’d like to work with City Staff and the Mayor to have a statement prepared about the Moorlands traffic impact.
Mayor Herbig said that the school district’s financial forecast is dire. It puts them into a tough corner with this. We all need to put pressure on the State to fund education as its paramount duty, so that these decisions don’t have to come down to the school districts. It’s not great for the long-term health of the School District. We need to do better for our kids.